Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Johnathan A. Doody Conviction of Killing 9 Buddhists in 1991 Overturned

Johnathan A. Doody Conviction of Killing 9 Buddhists in 1991 Overturned


Late in the evening of August 9, 1991, Alessandro Garcia and then 15-yr old Jonathan A. Doody drove to the Phoenix Buddhist temple in Doody's 1983 Ford Mustang. Doody was staying with Garcia to finish high school after his parents moved to Colorado, and had a brother who had studied at the temple, and heard of a gold Buddha and spent two months planning a robbery which evolved into a war-game with military equipment and tactics. They burst in and ordered the monks to the floor. They arranged them in a circle, kneeling and facing one another, and for the next hour they took turns holding them at gunpoint and ransacking the place. The monks had offered no resistance. At one point, a nun came in and she was forced to join the men. Six monks, a nun and two helpers were killed in a  robbery turned into a terrorist attack. Doody was 17 when he was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison, but his conviction was overturned in 2011 when a federal appeals court determined he was not properly read his rights and his confession was forced. 






Posted on October 14, 2013 at 8:06 AM
Updated yesterday at 1:54 PM
PHOENIX (AP) -- A jury has resumed deliberations in the case of a man charged in the 1991 killings of nine people at a suburban Phoenix Buddhist temple.

The panel on Monday resumed deliberations in the trial of 39-year-old Johnathan A. Doody following a break since Oct. 3.

That was the day that deliberations started over with an alternate joining the panel after another juror was excused Oct. 2.

The original panel started deliberating on Sept. 24. Doody's trial began Aug. 12.


A federal appeals court overturned Doody's conviction in 2011, noting he wasn't properly read his rights.


  1. Jury ends deliberations for day in temple killings - FOX 13 News

    www.myfoxtampabay.com/.../jury-to-return-tuesday-in-temple-killings-c...

    Oct 1, 2013 - Jonathan Doody ... Arizona executes its oldest inmate for 1978 killing ...in the case of a man charged in the 1991 killings of nine people at a suburban PhoenixBuddhist temple. Johnathan A. Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robbery.

  2. Jurors in Buddhist temple killings finish for the day ... - America Now

    www.americanownews.com/.../jurors-in-buddhist-temple-killings-finish-f...

    1 day ago - (Source: CBS 5 News). PHOENIX (AP/CBS5) - ... Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robberyHe was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison . A federal appeals court ... JONATHAN DOODY COVERAGE. JONATHAN DOODY ...

  3. Jury to return Monday in temple killings case - | KSWT 13 On Your ...

    www.kswt.com/story/.../no-verdict-yet-in-buddhist-temple-killings-case

    Sep 26, 2013 - PHOENIX (AP) - A jury has concluded its third day of deliberations without a verdict in the case of a man charged in ... Johnathan A. Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robberyHe was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison.

  4. Deliberations resume in Buddhist temple killings - | KSWT 13 On ...

    www.kswt.com/story/.../deliberations-resume-in-buddhist-temple-killings

    1 day ago - PHOENIX (AP) - A jury is scheduled to resume deliberations in the case of a man charged in the 1991 killings of nine people at a ... Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robberyHe was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison .

  5. Deliberations to resume in Buddhist temple deaths - | KSWT 13 On ...

    www.kswt.com/story/.../deliberations-to-resume-in-buddhist-temple-deat...

    5 hours ago - PHOENIX (AP) - Jurors in the trial of a man charged in the 1991 killings of nine people at a suburban Phoenix Buddhist temple ... Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robberyHe was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison.

  6. Juror dismissed from Ariz temple killings re-trial - | KSWT 13 On Your ...

    www.kswt.com/story/.../jury-to-resume-deliberations-in-temple-killings

    Oct 2, 2013 - PHOENIX (AP) - A juror has been dismissed from the re-trial of a man charged in the 1991 killings of nine people at ... Johnathan A. Doody was 17 when authorities say he participated in the gunning down of six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robberyHe was convicted in 1993 and sentenced to 281 years in prison.

  7. Johnathan Doody Goes On Retrial For Buddhist Temple Killings

    www.huffingtonpost.com/.../johnathan-doody-retrial_n_3789267.html

    Aug 21, 2013 - PHOENIX — Jurors at the retrial of an Arizona man charged with the 1991 murders of nine ... friend who said they went to the house of worship to carry out arobbery... Doody is accused of killing six monks, a nun and two helpers during a robbery... taken when Doody was 17, wasn't given voluntarily, partly because he  ...



  1. TEAM KILLERS: MALE — The Good and the Bad — Crime Library ...

    www.trutv.com/library/crime/serial_killers/partners/team.../7.html

    Jul 1, 2002 - It began as a plan for a robbery, Alessandro Garcia admitted in his long and self- serving ... He and Jonathan Doody had plotted it for two months after hearing from Jonathans ... The Buddhists monks at the temple west of PhoenixArizona near Luke Air Force ... At one point, a nun came in and she was forced to join the men.


     began as a plan for a robbery, Alessandro Garcia admitted in his long and self-serving statement to police. He and Jonathan Doody had plotted it for two months after hearing from Jonathans brother about the solid gold Buddha and the safe that contained $2000. The Buddhists monks at the temple west of Phoenix, Arizona near Luke Air Force base also kept money under their mattresses. It seemed like easy pickings, and to build their courage, they turned their "mission" into a "war game."
    They purchased military clothing and harnesses with knives, then borrowed a rifle and 20-guage shotgun. Late in the evening of August 9, 1991, they drove to the temple in Doody's 1983 Ford Mustang. They checked it out and then left, returning around 15 minutes later. Then they burst in and ordered the monks to the floor. They arranged them in a circle, kneeling and facing one another, and for the next hour they took turns holding them at gunpoint and ransacking the place. The monks had offered no resistance. At one point, a nun came in and she was forced to join the men.
    They placed what they took into two military duffel bags. The temple did have a safe but they couldn't find a key to get it open. Doody wanted to ensure there would be no witnesses, and that meant killing everyone there. Standing on a couch above the monks, he just began shooting them, shooting them in the back of the head. He went from one to another, and if the first shot appeared not to have killed the victim, he'd shoot again. In the end, nine people lay dead in a circle. Garcia used the back of a knife to carve the word "Bloods" on the wall in the hallway, hoping to deflect the police, and together they sprayed the place with fire extinguishers.
    It took almost two months, but the military police spotted the rifle and it was confiscated for testing. They had a match, and a link to a killer: Jonathan Doody. He lived with Garcia and a search of their apartment turned up the shotgun.

  2. All about the Buddhist Temple Massacre — Epilogue — Crime ...

    www.trutv.com/library/crime/criminal_mind/forensics/.../13.html

    Aug 23, 2003 - When nine people are massacred in a Buddhist temple in Goodyear,Arizona... While away from the scene, someone started shooting people. ... He and Doody had obsessed about it for two months, because they had ... The monks did not resist. ... On July 12, 1993Jonathan Doody was convicted of nine murders and 11 ...

  3. the entire arizona republic coverage of jonathan doody - APFN

    www.apfn.net/dcia/doody91.html

    Sep 5, 1997 - 2. The worst mass slaying in modern Arizona history, which led to one of the state's most ... The victims were six Buddhist monks, an elderly nun, a templehelper and a ... On Oct. 28, Phoenix area teens Alex Garcia, 16, and Jonathan Doody17..... Leslie Hoover, that he, Doody and ''some of his friends'' were involvedin the ...

  4. Youth Pleads Guilty to Buddhist Massacre : Murder: He agrees to ...

    articles.latimes.com/1993-01-07/news/mn-980_1_death-penalty

    Jan 7, 1993 - 17-year-old youth pleaded guilty Wednesday to nine counts of first-degree murder in ... with the August, 1991, massacre of six monks and three others at a Buddhist temple. ... Gregory Martin that he and his friend, Johnathan Doody, acted alone in the robbery and killings at the Wat Promkunaram temple west of Phoenix.

  5. Affidavit Says Boy Confessed In Slaying Of Buddhist Monks - New ...

    www.nytimes.com/.../affidavit-says-boy-confessed-in-slaying-of-buddhis...

    Oct 31, 1991 - The statement attributed to Jonathan Doody17 years old, was contained in a search warrant affidavit obtained Tuesday by the Arizona Republic. ...17, Alessandro Garcia, 16, and about seven others took part in the robbery and killings. ... believe the six Thai monks, a temple helper, a monk in training, and an elderly nun...

  6. Confession in '91 Arizona Buddhist Temple Massacre Thrown Out

    www.crimefilenews.com/2008/.../confession-in-91-arizona-buddhist.htm...

    Nov 21, 2008 - Their own brother Michael Miller was one of the murdered templehelpers... Later that night I went to the home of those two teens in search of interviews. ... 17 year-old, Jonathan Doody was relentlessly sweated by police until he.... Frank Fastner of RTL German TV and Debra Milke Leaving the Court PhoenixAZ --For the ...

  7. Thai American Murderer's Conviction Overturned In America ...

    www.thaivisa.com › Thailand Forum › General › General topics

     Rating: 5 - ‎1 vote
    Nov 21, 2008 - Jonathan Doody was one of two youths found guilty of the infamous Temple Murders and ... man convicted of killing nine people at a Buddhist temple west of Phoenix in 1991. ... for the slayings of six priests, a nun and two helpers during a robbery at the Wat ... He has spent 17 years at the state prison in Florence, Arizona.

  8. New trial ordered in 1991 Buddhist temple killings - AZCentral.com

    www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/local/.../20081121doody1121.html

    Nov 21, 2008 - Jonathan Doody was one of two youths convicted of the infamous temple ... who handles appeals for the Arizona Attorney General's Office, said that he... "It's always difficult to retry a case 15 or so years down the road," said ... Doody, then 17 and a junior in high school, was arrested after investigators ... phoenixbusiness ...
  9. [PDF]

    Nonfiction: A Place of Peace—A Place of Blood - Lawyers

    www.myazbar.org/AZAttorney/PDF_Articles/0508GaryStuart.pdf

    May 1, 2008 - the Arizona Buddhist temple, the thermometer was a simple indi- cator of... sense of safety to the monksnuns, acolytes and bell ringers who live and ... To avoid the six-inch-deep, 50-foot-diameter pool of water ... the two ends of the line dangling at an odd ... He and Borders ran back to his house while Hash waited outside.

  10. Assistant Attorney General Joseph Maziarz Honored | Arizona ...

    https://www.azag.gov/.../assistant-attorney-general-joseph-maziarz-honor...

    Jul 24, 2007 - He has represented the State of Arizona as an appellate prosecutor in more than ... Rudi and Michael Apelt, two brothers from Germany who devised and carried ... Rogelio Gutierrez, who caused a car accident that burned Phoenix Police ...Jonathan Doody, who murdered nine people, including six monks and a nun at a  ...



    1. Johnathan Doody Trial: Closing Arguments Set In Buddhist Temple ...

      www.huffingtonpost.com/.../johnathan-doody-trial-buddhist-temple-mur...
      Sep 23, 2013 - Their bodies were found arranged face-down in a circle... "he wasn't really into it " and pointed the shotgun mainly at the ground when he fired.
    2. Confession at center of Doody retrial in Buddhist temple killlings

      www.azcentral.com › Community › Surprise
      Aug 13, 2013
      Confession at center of Doody retrial in Buddhist temple killlings,On Monday, ... helpers lying facedown and ...
    3. TEAM KILLERS: MALE — The Good and the Bad — Crime Library ...

      www.trutv.com/library/crime/serial_killers/partners/team.../7.html
      He and Jonathan Doody had plotted it for two months after hearing from Jonathans brother about the solid gold Buddha and the safe that contained $2000. ... clothing and harnesses with knives, then borrowed a rifle and 20- guage shotgun... They arranged them in a circle, kneeling and facing one another, and for the next ...
    4. All about the Buddhist Temple Massacre — Epilogue — Crime ...

      www.trutv.com/library/crime/criminal_mind/.../buddhist.../13.html
      When nine people are massacred in a Buddhist temple in Goodyear, Arizona, ...Doody, too, eventually offered a confession and he described events quite ... Doodyborrowed the rifle from Caratachea and Garcia smuggled his uncle's shotgun out ...They arranged them in a circle, kneeling and facing one another, and for an ...

No comments:

Post a Comment