Wednesday, June 5, 2019

Hakiakat Singh Pannang Sikh Household of 4 Murdered in Ohio

Hakiakat Singh Pannang Sikh Household of 4 Murdered in Ohio --- ===

4 killed in mass shooting no suspect April 28, 2019 Hakiakat Singh Pannang Sikh Household of 4 Murdered in Ohio Four people, a man and his wife, sister and daughter  were found all killed by gunshots by husband of the daughter Gurpreet Singh. He was questioned as a witness. India's minister of external affairs responded that they do not believe it was hate crime, as one was a visiting Indian national, and the others were of Indian origin man (2)  Sikh religion.  Authorities have ruled out robbery or murder-suicide [5] As of June, no suspects had been identified but  they believe the shooting wasn't random. (6) 

preliminary analysis indicates 59-year-old Hakiakat Singh Pannang Panag, wife 62-year-old Pamrjit Kaur, 58-year-old sister in law Amarjit Kaur and daughter 39-year-old Shalinderjit Kaur. Panag’s son in law, Shalinder Kaur's husband, Gurpreet Singh, (7) returned to his West Chester Township home and found much of his family on the floor bleeding to death. The victim's brother in law
called 911 at about 9:40 p.m. Sunday and said his wife and three other family members were on the ground and bleeding. “No one’s talking, no one’s talking,” he shouted.  When the call taker asked if it looked like they had been shot or stabbed, he said he didn’t know and that he had just gotten home. A neighbor also called 911 and said there was a man running around the apartment building telling people to call police.  “He’s just banging on the doors screaming, ‘Please call the police, please call the police, please help me,‘” she said. (2).(1)  Herzog said police questioned the man as a witness, but police as of June had not named any suspects or persons of interest. There is no sign of forced entry. Police divers came and recovered something that could be a gun.  Preliminary analysis indicates victims  were all shot to death around 9:50 p.m, oddly about ten minutes after the 911 call, and all died of gunshot wounds (2)   Chowkidar Sushma Swaraj, the Indian minister of external affairs, tweeted Tuesday that she was aware of the crime and did not believe it to be a hate crime.  One of them was an Indian national on a visit to US while others were persons of Indian origin man (2) and all  worshiped the Sikh religion.  Authorities have ruled out reasons such as hate crime, robbery or murder-suicide [5] As of June, no suspects had been identified but  they believe the shooting wasn't random. (6) 

Alternative theory: Was somebody recruited in a clandestine attack to kill his family members and either blame it on a suspect who got away or make it look like some domestic violence issue? Why is the brother in law not even a person of interest as typically the first suspect in a domestic case is a family member and he's the only one around at the time of the shootings? Family members have been known to kill other family members in cult and terrorist cases.

Similar - man targets landlord office rather his Sikh family for no apparent reason: April 1, 2019  Chad Isaak Workplace Mass Murder in North Dakota Chad Isaak, a chiropractor from Washburn, is suspected of mass murder where he killed by stabbing and shooting every one working at RJR Maintenance and Management in Mandan North Dakota which manages the trailer park where he lives for no clear motive.  [1] [2]


4 people found dead in an Iowa house after guest runs out and asks bystander to call 911... CNN   Four people were found dead inside their West Des Moines, Iowa, home, police said on Saturday. All four had apparent gunshot wounds. Chandrasekhar Sunkara, 44; Lavanya Sunkara, 41; and two boys, ages 15 and 10 were pronounced dead at the scene, the city of West Des Moines said in a news release. They were found Saturday morning, according to CNN affiliate KCCI. Four other family members, two of whom are children, were staying in the home as guests, police said. When the victims were found, one of those guests ran outside to look for help, found someone walking by and had that person call 911.  does not appear to be a threat to others in the community.

Anti-Sikh incidents are rare: Wisconsin Sikh temple shooting August 5, 2012 Wisconsin Sikh temple shooting (KKK inspired) massacre took place at the gurdwara (Sikh temple) in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, ...

*Tags

  • Asian victim (sikh)
  • Asian suspect
  • Domestic terror
  • Indian victim
  • Mass shooting
  • Ohio
  • Own family target
  • Sikh incident

*Footnotes
  1. After a quadruple homicide, an Ohio faith leader is left to explain what happened Herald mail Keith BieryGolick Apr 30, 2019   Why, he was asked, did he think someone would kill 
  2. West Chester Township quadruple homicide not a hate crime, Indian  official said   4 found dead in West Chester apartment Sunday    https://www.wcpo.com/breaking.../four-found-dead-in-west-chester-apartment-buildin...   Apr 28, 2019 - WEST CHESTER TOWNSHIP, Ohio —brother in law called 911 at about 9:40 p.m. Sunday and said his wife and three other family members were on the ground and bleeding. “No one’s talking, no one’s talking,” he shouted.  When the call taker asked if it looked like they had been shot or stabbed, he said he didn’t know and that he had just gotten home. Herzog said police questioned the man as a witness. A neighbor also called 911 and said there was a man running around the apartment building telling people to call police.  “He’s just banging on the doors screaming, ‘Please call the police, please call the police, please help me,‘” she said.  Chowkidar Sushma Swaraj, the Indian minister of external affairs, tweeted Tuesday that she was aware of the crime and did not believe it to be a hate crime. ndian Ambassador in United States @IndianEmbassyUS has informed me about the killing of four persons in Cincinnati on Sunday evening. One of them was an Indian national on a visit to US while others were persons of Indian origin man 
  3. Report: Family in India grieving for West Chester shooting victims  https://www.wcpo.com May 2, 2019 - The victims were 59-year-old Hakikat Singh Panag and his three female family members — 62-year-old Paramjit Kaur, 58-year-old Amarjit Kaur ...
  4. 4 found dead in West Chester apartment Sunday    https://www.wcpo.com/breaking.../four-found-dead-in-west-chester-apartment-buildin...   
  5. Hunt still on for the killer in Sikh quadruple murder case in Ohio  americanbazaaronline  May 9, 2019 - Four members of Sikh family – Hakikat Singh Panag, his nd the visiting relative from India ...
  6. Services held for 4 relatives slain in Ohio; no suspect ID'd - WCPO.com  June 2, 2019  said Monday that the six people were killed after Sunday services. previously said
  7. West Chester shooting: Sikh family want answers; no killer found  cincinnati.com May 8, 2019 - Last week's West Chester quadruple murder has sent waves of shock and grief all over the world. ... Killed were Shalinder Kaur, 39, her parents, Hakiakat Singh Panag, 59, and Parmjit Kaur, 62, and her sister Amarjit Kaur, 58. They were found by Shalinder Kaur
  8. 's husband, Gurpreet Singh, (7)

*Sources


Sikh family shooting: West Chester man describes finding wife, others ...
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/crime/crime...family.../1114492001/

May 5, 2019 - Gurpreet Singh, the sole surviving adult male of the West Chester quadruple murders, has been coming to the Sikh temple daily, to pray for the ...

Manhunt is underway for suspect after Ohio Sikh family is killed - CNN ...
https://www.cnn.com/.../ohio-apartment-killing-sikh-family-shot-casey-jordan-intv-ots-v...

May 1, 2019 - Four members of a Sikh family were found shot dead in their West Chester Township, Ohio, apartment, a few miles north of Cincinnati.

Four family members found shot dead in Ohio apartment complex
https://nypost.com/.../four-family-members-found-shot-dead-in-ohio-apartment-comp...

Apr 29, 2019 - A group of four family members were discovered shot to death ... The president of a local Sikh temple said the family worshiped there and ...

West Chester shooting victims remembered as 'beautiful family' at Sikh ...
https://www.wcpo.com/.../west-chester-shooting-victims-remembered-as-beautiful-fam...

Apr 29, 2019 - WEST CHESTER TOWNSHIP, Ohio — Jasminder Singh, president of the Guru Nanak Society Sikh Gurudwara Sahib of Greater Cincinnati, ...
Wikipedia: Four family members, three women and one man, were found shot to death in an apartment in West Chester Township, Ohio. The suspect remains at large. (NBC News)


West Chester shooting victim named by religious leader  https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/crime/crime-and-courts/.../3615809002/
 Apr 29, 2019 - Singh said Hakikat Panag was one of the four people killed at the apartment complex Sunday evening. At a service Monday evening at the Sikh ..



No comments:

Post a Comment