tags: july 2014, air incident, zionist, palestinian suspect, islamphobia, anti-semitism, corporate anti-semitism, jewish victim, pro-Israel, micro-terrorism
July 7, 2014 Palestinian Asks JetBlue To Remove Doctor As Zionist Threat In West Palm Beach, Florida Dr. Lisa Rosenberg was heading home to New York when she was forced to leave a plane about to take off after a woman who identified herself as palestinian called her a "zionist pig" after she completed a phone call about violence in Israel, and how some people made murderers "out to be martyrs and celebrating them." Rosenberg was shocked that the woman complained to the crew she could not be comfortable flying with "me, a Jewish doctor", and was escorted by a police officer after being asked to leave the plane. She felt victimized by anti-semitism and harassed, especially after she was the one being accused of being harassed and a security threat and forced to leave by police. The airline confirmed she had been asked to leave, but denied her story and declined to provide any details of what "really" happened. wpbf video
Alternate theory: Is the zionist the real terrorist here, and will homeland security ever investigate this thinly veiled attack on jewish and pro-Israel passengers?
Video
*Sources
JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane ...
www.wpbf.com/news/jetblue-releases-report-about.../26973238
by Ari Hait - 7 days ago - A Jewish woman was kicked off a JetBlue Airways flight because she was disruptive and accused another passenger of having explosives in ...WPBF
A Jewish woman was kicked off a JetBlue Airways flight because she was disruptive and accused another passenger of having explosives in her bag, according to a report by the airline.
"A woman comes up to me and says to me, ‘I'm a Palestinian’ and she starts cursing at me. 'Zionist pig. This is just the beginning,'" Rosenberg said.
The two women argued until a flight attendant intervened. Rosenberg said she was asked to leave the flight shortly after. She said JetBlue never explained why she was being removed but she believed it was because she was Jewish.
The woman with whom she was arguing declined an interview but she has posted her side of the story on wpbf.com. She claimed she told Rosenberg her phone call was offensive.
in the report obtained by WPBF 25 News, the flight attendant writes Rosenberg "accused customer 9C of being a Palestinian murderer, and that her people are all murderers, and that they murder children. She went even further to suggest 9C had explosives in her bag and it would bring the aircraft down." That's when Rosenberg was asked to leave the flight, the report says.
anti-semitic comments:
RJ O'Guillory • 2 days ago ..."who's to blame"?....how about the liars and thieves from Europe who decided to call themselves "Jews"...and went about stealing the land from the indigenous people of Palestine in 1948....
SacJP Kim Jong-Il • 2 hours ago
You mean the semitic jews, the ones who have brown skin and who now call themselves arabs most having converted to Islam? I'm pretty sure they were there first. They were made homeless because their home was forcibly taken from them by the zionist european jews (regardless of what you choose to call the displaced Palestinians or their land.) The ironic thing is that the so-called "children of Israel" have actually occupied the home of the true descendants of the tribe of Israel (who are now mostly muslim.)
ratnn boboadobo • 2 days ago GOOD! I will use them (Jet Blue) for future flights. You want to understand the arrogance of the good Doc then google "The Talmud's death wish" and watch the vid.
SacJP SacJP • You mean the semitic jews, the ones who have brown skin and who now call themselves arabs most having converted to Islam? I'm pretty sure they were there first. They were made homeless because their home was forcibly taken from them by the zionist european jews (regardless of what you choose to call the displaced Palestinians or their land.) The ironic thing is that the so-called "children of Israel" have actually occupied the home of the true descendants of the tribe of Israel (who are now mostly muslim.) [this is some pro-muslim pro-russian disinfo agent ]Umm, the legitimately and democratically elected Donetsk Peoples' Republic, which won by a landslide in a fair and free election, informed the world that they closed this airspace days before this incident. The rogue regime in Kiev, that happens to be a puppet of western powers, nonetheless claimed authority over airspace they didn't control and had no moral right to exercise authority over, and told the world that the airspace was fine to fly through over 10,000 meters...SacJP This is the exact same conclusion I came to as well... Whoever shot down the plane, whether the Donetsk Peoples' Republic by mistake, or the junta in Kiev as a false flag, the blame lies with the Kiev regime and with us in the west who installed them.SacJP • 5 days ago
1. Whoever shot down the (civilian) plane almost certainly didn't do so on purpose, so this would fall squarely under the heading of "collateral damage" (which the United States and Kiev junta are even more guilty of thousands of times over.)
2. Now there's also the possibility that one side *intentionally* shot down a civilian plane trying to pin it on the other side, but if this did occur it almost certainly would've been done by the pro-US/EU/Kiev side and not by the freedom fighters.
3. In other words whoever did it, it's almost certainly Kiev's fault (and indirectly the U.S. and EU's fault as well for installing that regime.)
- *If* it was the freedom fighters then Kiev is to blame because they should've already shut down the airspace over the active war zone, especially after the rebels made a big deal out of having captured high altitude anti-aircraft weapons (which makes '2' above a distinct possibility, but only on the Kiev-perpetrated side of the equation.)
- If it was Kiev directly, then of course they are responsible themselves.
Of course the airline also shares a fair amount of blame for flying their planes over an active war zone.
I'm inclined to believe that it probably was the freedom fighters, by accident, and that the puppet government in Kiev left the airspace open hoping that something like this would happen.
However I also wouldn't be surprised though if it was a false flag by some western intelligence agents embedded with the freedom fighters, or even just pretending to be them. That's kinda the normal mode of operation on the U.S./Israeli side.
22/07/14 - She is a terrible doctor! And especially after I read this in the news! No one should ever have to go to this doctor for harassing a woman like this! She cursed out an innocent woman on the plane and accused her of carrying bombs in her bag and she was escorted out of the plane with cops because of her bad behaviour...no one should ever have to deal with a woman like this!!! http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/n-y-jewish-...
jetblue - WPBF.com
www.wpbf.com/...jetblue-report-offers-details-of-why-woman-kic...
by Ari Hait - New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane. UPDATED 8:16 AM EDT Jul 16, 2014. Tweet · Next Video: Man creates spreadsheet of ...WPBF
New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why ... - YouTube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dPhZiVXNpg
6 days ago - Uploaded by WPBF 25 News
New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane. WPBF 25 News. SubscribeSubscribedUnsubscribe 6,969 ...New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman ...
news.yahoo.com/.../details-jetblue-report-offers-details-131...
6 days ago - Watch the video New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane on Yahoo News . A woman is claiming anti-Semitism ...Yahoo! News
New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman ...
www.dailymotion.com/.../x21myqg_ne...
Dailymotion
5 days ago
Business owner accused of running Ponzi scheme · 02:17. New Details: JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane ..http://forward.com/articles/202059/jewish-doctor-bounced-from-jetblue-flight-over-gaz/
After the phone call concluded, Rosenberg said a woman approached her, identified herself as a Palestinian, and the two then had an “ugly, racially driven altercation” in which the other woman called her a “Zionist pig,” according to media reports.
But a commenter on the website Gothamist, who identified herself as the passenger who confronted Rosenberg, said that Rosenberg “was the only person yelling and actually said a Palestinian on the flight was a ‘danger to her’.
She was removed from that flight for making a scene, refusing to sit in her seat and not complying with staff. Other passengers , if they come forward, will verify this.”
JetBlue confirmed that it asked Rosenberg to exit the plane, which was still on the ground in Florida and said that Rosenberg’s account is not accurate.
“The story presented in no way reflects the reports from our crew, whose decision to remove the customer we support,” the airline said in a statement.
A JetBlue spokeswoman told JTA that the details of the incident
· 1 week ago
First of all, why discuss this topic on your cell phone as you are about to depart on a flight? And loud enough that you are overheard. Bad manners. Second, then, instead of ignoring the approaching woman, you inflame the situation by arguing with someone who identifies herself as Palestinian. Since you are intelligent enough to be a physician, did your intelligence deflate when you finished your too loud phone call? Third, if you were loud enough that the crew had to step in, then they were within their job description to remove you from the flight. It had nothing to do with being a Jew. It had everything to do with not using common sense. All of those diplomas hanging on the wall don't make you a superior being. Next time have sense enough to walk away. As another poster said, quoting Abraham Lincoln, "Better to be silent and thought a fool, than to speak and remove all doubt."
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 6 days ago
Loading...
+32 Vote up Vote down
Lenewyorkais's avatar - Go to profile
Lenewyorkais 76p · 1 week ago
as a wise Supreme Court justice once said, "Your right to free speech does not extend to your right to yell fire in a crowded theater."
Airplanes r potentially dangerous places. Passengers r expected to show a certain amount of restraint against passionate discussions about politics or religion. There r many other venus for the doctor to safely exercise her right to free speech.
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 1 week ago
Loading...
+24 Vote up Vote down
Julius_Baer's avatar - Go to profile
Julius_Baer 58p · 6 days ago
According to JetBlue's report, Rosenberg was kicked off the flight for refusing to take her seat when asked to by the flight attendant -- and then suggesting that the Palestinian woman had explosives in her bag and planned to blow up the plane. ANYONE would be kicked off a plane for behavior like this, regardless of their ethnicity or whether or not someone else's comment provoked the behavior. In fact, if that part about the false reporting of a bomb is true, Rosenberg is lucky she wasn't arrested and in serious legal trouble. This perhaps explains why the previously loquacious doctor is suddenly speaking only through an attorney. In any event, the suggestion above that people who discuss any other version of this story but Rosenberg's are "ghetto Jews" who are "ashamed and intimidated to mention their Jewish heritage or defend Israel in public" is of course asinine -- though to be sure no more so than the usual clownservative ranting on these threads.
I can't post the links here, but you can find fuller accounts by googling these headlines: "JetBlue report offers details of why woman kicked off plane" and "Dear Dr. Rosenberg, Jetblue Didn’t Throw You Off For Being Jewish".
Report
Reply
Loading...
+22 Vote up Vote down
Stonington's avatar - Go to profile
Stonington 78p · 1 week ago
Airlines don't care about political views, religious or ethnic affiliation but they do care very much about behavior that's disruptive. If Dr Rosenberg was removed from the flight it was most likely because she was seen as being disruptive, not for being Jewish or any particular point of view. In any case, given airport and airline security concerns it's just not sensible for anyone to behave in any way that will give rise to attention or concern -- no matter what another passenger may say. (Ever if a fellow passenger were to say something like, "I'd like to see all the Jews dead," the best sort of response would be something like a "how sweet of you, dearie" and leave it at that.)
Report
Reply
4 replies · active 6 days ago
Loading...
+9 Vote up Vote down
Arie Newman's avatar - Go to profile
Arie Newman 97p · 1 week ago
“I said any other country would have made these students out to be martyrs and celebrating them.” It so happens that the Anti-Defamation League, in an effort to determine what the level of anti-Semitism is worldwide, gauges that level by the percentage of people who agree with such statements as, "Jews believe they are better than other people." If someone agrees with the statement, the ADL views it as a sign they are anti-Semitic. And yet here is a physician (not some ignorant person whose lack of education might help us understand their bigotry...), announcing to the world that she does think HER tribe is better. She's an embarrassment to our tribe and to America.
Report
Reply
4 replies · active 6 days ago
+8 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
@Eastwooden · 1 week ago
Could happen an all airlines, and can be justified.
Rosenberg claims she said "“I said any other country would have made these students out to be martyrs and celebrating them.”
Me, as a Jewish citizen of a Western democracy, I feel also offended by her statement.
More still: she apparently said many other things she didn't mention to Tablet.
I commend jetBlue for their prompt and appropriate reaction and decision.
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 1 week ago
+7 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Jacob Arnon · 1 week ago
Oh sure, the Arabs or Muslims are never the aggressors, it's always others who provoke them first.
And Jews are always guilty until proven innocent.
Report
Reply
+6 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Myron Chaitovsky · 6 days ago
The mail system does not alow for a URL, but if you search for "Dr Lisa Rosenberg Jet Blue", you will see a whole different side, Jet Blue's side, to this tempest in a teapot--and it should be embarrasing to readers of The Forward and other human beings.
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 6 days ago
Loading...
+5 Vote up Vote down
Judeneveragain's avatar - Go to profile
Judeneveragain 80p · 1 week ago
By all accounts the Palestinian woman started the confrontation, i don't know exactly what she said but a reasonable person can assume that it wasn't that she like Dr. Rosenberg's hairdo. If i were walking on a street and a Palestinian confronted me suddenly about Gaza i would be somewhat upset; even more so if it occured in the confines of an airplane and my voice might rise a bit too. whether it was right or wrong for jet blue, kudos to Dr. Rosenberg for standing up for her rights.
Report
Reply
+4 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Bill Pearlman · 1 week ago
This comment has been deleted by the administrator.
Report
1 reply · active 1 week ago
+4 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Suhail Shafi · 4 days ago
Good. If Arabs can be booted from planes for misbehaving, so can Jews.
Report
Reply
Loading...
+3 Vote up Vote down
No_Opinion's avatar - Go to profile
No_Opinion 1p · 1 week ago
While I don't know any of the details surrounding this event I do personally know Dr. Rosenberg. I can assure you there is much more to the story than she would have you believe. Use your brain when considering your opinion about this report. It certainly doesn't make any sense that she was the only one removed from the flight if her account is accurate and complete.
I am a Jew, and I fully support the IDF actions taken to defend the Israeli citizens. But I believe Dr. Rosenberg is inflating this incident to grab her own 15 minutes (or hopefully only 15 seconds) of fame at the expense of others. I will be surprised if there isn't an organized effort by the Jewish community to boycott JetBlue for their reported actions, however it will be a shame to see a company suffer any financial losses from a less-than-truthful account of this situation.
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 1 week ago
Loading...
+2 Vote up Vote down
Move_along_pls's avatar - Go to profile
Move_along_pls 84p · 1 week ago
But a commenter on the website Gothamist, who identified herself as the passenger who confronted Rosenberg, said that Rosenberg “was the only person yelling and actually said a Palestinian on the flight was a ‘danger to her’. She was removed from that flight for making a scene, refusing to sit in her seat and not complying with staff. Other passengers , if they come forward, will verify this.”
must be true, from such an unbiased source.
Anyway, flight crew can remove anyone for any behaviour deemed disruptive - including the colour of your skin or your last name having too many vowels. A few years ago a 17 year old was detained at gunpoint for wrapping tefillin. At least in that case the airline, while defending their crew, also apologized for their ignorance.
Report
Reply
8 replies · active 6 days ago
Loading...
+1 Vote up Vote down
LukeF33's avatar - Go to profile
LukeF33 71p · 1 week ago
Israel's enemies keep attacking Israel, and then Israel defends itself and smacks the enemies around, and then idiots around the world chime in to criticize Israel for smacking around morons who refuse to accept peace with Israel.
Report
Reply
1 reply · active 1 week ago
0 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Michael Reichmann · 20 hours ago
The reason this happened is because people need to mind their own business and quit stickin their noses in somebody else's conversation....plain and simple...... God bless Israel and their glorious military....they will always be victorious.
Report
Reply
Loading...
-1 Vote up Vote down
joe_r's avatar - Go to profile
joe_r -34p · 1 week ago
This comment has been deleted by the administrator.
Report
1 reply · active 1 week ago
Loading...
-4 Vote up Vote down
obaidah1111's avatar - Go to profile
obaidah1111 33p · 1 day ago
It is interesting to see that for you feeling something about the murdered children in the wombs of their mothers by a state that is officially, according to the international laws accepted by everybody, occupies other peoples lands, is anti-Semitism. NO: if we keep our awareness about a genocide that happened 60 years ago somewhere in Europe, we should keep ourselves sensitive about the genocide, state-terror and apartheid happening TODAY. Blinding oneself and still supporting the state-terror is a shame. Israel is today's Third Reich, and you lost your human feelings for the victims of genocide, apartheid, and murder of people in their own lands.
Critique of Israeli apartheid, genocide, state-terror and murder is a human responsibility. Many Jews around the world join in this human struggle to non-Jews. Those who support Israel are supporting war criminals and fundamentalist neo-Nazis. Enough is enough.
Report
Reply
Loading...
-5 Vote up Vote down
k1122's avatar - Go to profile
k1122 -86p · 1 week ago
This comment has been deleted by the administrator.
Report
2 replies · active 1 week ago
Loading...
-9 Vote up Vote down
joe_r's avatar - Go to profile
joe_r -34p · 1 week ago
There is something very amateurish in your headline. It should be either an Israel-Palestine conflict or a Likud-Hamas conflict, not a Israel-Hamas conflict.
Report
Reply
6 replies · active 5 days ago
Loading...
-12 Vote up Vote down
AaronBear's avatar - Go to profile
AaronBear 74p · 1 week ago
I really dislike calls of anti-Semitism when they aren't clear. Almost always when watching a football game on TV and a player responds to another players cheap shot it is only the second player who is penalized. The official just didn't see the first violation and only saw the response. I can easily imagine that the flight attendant only saw the doctor replying loudly after the Palestinian woman 'got in her face'. Here's a lesson for us all. Should some scum sucking apologist for Arab terrorism get in your face, keep your voice low and when someone of authority arrives say something like 'thank goodness you came, this person threatened to strangle me'. Get them thrown off the plane, not you.
Report
Reply
-14 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Herb Grossman · 6 days ago
I am offended by the number of Jews replying to this article who are too ashamed and intimidated to mention their Jewish heritage or defend Israel in public, and defend their cowardice, here. Are there that many ghetto Jews still around? Perhaps they should explore Zionism and get up off their knees.
Report
Reply
Loading...
-16 Vote up Vote down
bobbloggerstein's avatar - Go to profile
bobbloggerstein 36p · 6 days ago
Boycott JetBlue
Report
Reply
Loading...
-17 Vote up Vote down
Genelevit's avatar - Go to profile
Genelevit 85p · 1 week ago
I support Lisa Rosenberg. She is a brave woman who could stand up for her people.
Report
Reply
3 replies · active 6 days ago
-19 Vote up Vote down
's avatar - Go to profile
Francis Albert Sinatra · 6 days ago
Only hope she sues the airline and gets a billion dollar settlement.
Report
Read more: http://forward.com/articles/202059/jewish-doctor-bounced-from-jetblue-flight-over-gaz/#ixzz38EHcmuIc
wftv
Jews forced off Jet Blue Flight « YWN Coffee Room
www.theyeshivaworld.com/.../jews-forced-off-jet-bl...
However the Jet Blue flight attended insisted that he has no right to sit in a different ...She called security, and asked him to leave the flight, However S. Handler ...Yeshiva World News
Jewish woman says racism to blame for her ... - YouTube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=muBNjENhcxI
1 day ago - Uploaded by WPBF 25 News
A woman is claiming anti-Semitism is to blame for her being thrown off a JetBlue flight leaving from Palm Beach ...wingspanportfolioadvisors.blogspot.com/.../jewish-doctor-thrown-off-jet...
WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. —A woman is claiming anti-Semitism is to blame for her being thrown off a JetBlue flight leaving from Palm Beach International AirportJewish woman says racism to blame for her removal ... - Bing
www.bing.com/videos/watch/.../jewish...to...plane.../1d0kfy1ou
A woman is claiming anti-Semitism is to blame for her being thrown off a JetBlue flight leaving from Palm Beach International Airport this week. Reporter Ari Hair ...Bing
Woman kicked off plane at PBIA after argument about Israel ...
2 days ago - A Jewish woman was kicked off a JetBlue flight Monday night at Palm ...Dr. Lisa Rosenberg, a physician from New York, was returning home ...
Jewish woman says racism to blame for her removal from ...
www.wpbf.com/news/jewish-woman-says...to.../26893076
by Ari Hait - 1 day ago - JetBlue confirms Lisa Rosenberg removed from flight ... passenger, didn't feel comfortable with me, the Jewish doctor being on the plane?'".WPBF
Jewish Doctor Thrown Off Jet Blue Flight For Allegedly ...
wingspanportfolioadvisors.blogspot.com/.../jewish-doctor-thrown-off-jet...
Jewish Doctor Thrown Off Jet Blue Flight For Allegedly Harassing Palestinian ... Lisa Rosenberg had boarded a flight home to New York Monday night after her ...Latest from Aleese Kopf - Palm Beach Daily News
www.palmbeachdailynews.com/staff/.../stories/
A Jewish woman was kicked off a JetBlue flight at Palm Beach International Airport ...Dr. Lisa Rosenberg, a physician from New York, was returning home from ...Palm Beach Daily News
No comments:
Post a Comment